Are we teaching boys to become strong men, or teaching them to hide the very things that make them human?
International Men's Day is this week, and it gives us an opportunity to recognise the positive contributions men make to their families, workplaces and communities. It's also an opportunity to have some honest conversations about the challenges men face and the kind of messages we're passing on to the next generation.
One of those conversations needs to be about masculinity.
And increasingly, about the influence of what's known as the manosphere.
I've been thinking about this because of the conversations I have with men across Australia, but also because of my own experience and my complicated relationship with resilience.
For much of my life, I believed being a good man meant working hard, providing for my family, taking responsibility and getting on with whatever needed doing.
There is nothing wrong with those values. I'm proud of many of them.
But I also know what happens when they become the only things you use to measure your worth.
When I walked away from the farm, I didn't just lose a business. I lost a huge part of my identity.
I wasn't sure who I was without being a farmer.
And when you've spent years believing your value comes from what you do, what you provide and how much you can carry, losing those things can leave you in a very difficult place.
I didn't have the emotional capacity or the language to properly explain what I was going through.
That experience continues to shape how I think about men's mental health today.
What exactly are we teaching men?
The manosphere isn't one organisation or one ideology. It covers a wide range of online communities, influencers and conversations about men, masculinity and relationships.
Some of the content offers genuinely useful advice about physical health, discipline, motivation, finances and personal development.
And I can understand why young men are attracted to it.
They want purpose. They want confidence. They want belonging. They want to feel valued and have some control over their future.
I don't think we should dismiss any of those needs.
But parts of this online culture promote a much narrower message about what makes a successful man.
Be wealthy. Be physically dominant. Be attractive. Be in control. Never show weakness. Never let anyone see you struggling.
At times, the message goes further, encouraging distrust of women, resentment and the belief that men's problems can be solved through power over others.
That concerns me.
Not because I think masculinity is something we should be ashamed of, but because I wonder what happens to a young man's mental health when he believes he can never live up to the expectations being sold to him.
And whether we are helping him build an identity or creating another set of pressures he feels compelled to carry.
The mental health cost of constantly having to prove yourself
In 2025, Movember released research showing that 63% of the young men surveyed watched masculinity influencers.
Among those viewers, 27% reported feelings of worthlessness.
Those figures don't prove the content caused those feelings. But they raise important questions about the relationship between the messages young men consume and how they view themselves.
What interests me most is the pressure to constantly measure up.
What happens when you're not earning enough?
When you don't look like the bloke on the screen?
When your relationship falls apart?
When you lose your job or business?
When you don't have the answers?
When you are struggling with your mental health but believe that admitting it makes you less of a man?
I understand some of those questions far too well.
I also know that no amount of determination or hard work can guarantee life won't knock you around.
If the only version of masculinity we offer young men depends on being successful and in control, we risk leaving them without a sense of worth when life becomes uncertain.
We need to help men develop a sense of who they are that can survive the loss of what they do.
When strength becomes silence
I believe in strength.
I've seen remarkable examples of it in farming families, sporting clubs, workplaces and communities recovering from drought, flood and bushfire.
But some of the strongest men I've met are also the ones who have been willing to acknowledge how difficult life has become.
They aren't necessarily the loudest people in the room.
Sometimes they're the men who quietly admit they're exhausted, frightened, grieving or unsure what to do next.
We've got to stop confusing emotional suppression with strength.
There is a difference between being able to manage your emotions and believing you're not allowed to have them.
When men feel they must hide fear, sadness, disappointment or uncertainty, it can become harder to communicate with the people around them.
And sometimes the only emotion they feel comfortable expressing is anger.
That doesn't mean anger is wrong. But we need to be willing to explore what's sitting underneath it.
Is it grief? Shame? Fear? Exhaustion? A sense of failure?
Those are questions worth asking.
The danger of shame and isolation
One thing I have come to understand through both my own journey and the conversations I have with others is how difficult shame can be.
Shame about not coping.
Shame about financial struggles.
Shame about relationship breakdown.
Shame about feeling you have let your family down.
Shame about needing help.
And sometimes the shame of simply believing you're not the man you should be.
We talk about loneliness and isolation as mental health challenges, particularly in rural and remote communities.
But isolation isn't always geographical.
You can live in a city, work alongside hundreds of people, have thousands of online followers and still feel completely alone.
You can have mates you talk to every week without ever having a conversation about what's actually happening in your life.
The manosphere can offer men a sense of belonging. But if that belonging depends on never admitting vulnerability, I wonder how much genuine support it provides when life becomes difficult.
Being surrounded by people is not the same as feeling connected to them.
And connection shouldn't depend on pretending everything is okay.
We need to take the mental health implications seriously
According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2,425 men died by suicide in 2025, representing almost three-quarters of Australia's recorded suicide deaths.
Every one of those deaths represents a person, a family and a community affected by loss.
Suicide is complex. We cannot point to the manosphere, traditional masculinity or any single factor as the explanation.
Men experience mental health difficulties for many reasons, including financial stress, relationship difficulties, trauma, isolation, physical illness and loss of identity.
But we do have research showing that certain restrictive masculine expectations can make seeking support more difficult.
And I think we should be challenging any message that encourages men to hide distress, disconnect from others or view asking for help as weakness.
At the same time, we need to acknowledge that simply telling men to speak up isn't enough.
What happens when they do?
Are they listened to?
Can they access the right support?
Is it affordable and available where they live?
Can they build a relationship with someone they trust, or do they have to keep explaining their circumstances to someone new?
Continuity matters.
Men need to feel safe asking for support, but our communities, workplaces and services also need to be prepared to respond.
Capacity before crisis: Another way to understand strength
I've spent a lot of time challenging the way we talk about resilience.
Not because resilience is unimportant, but because I know what it feels like when resilience becomes another expectation placed on someone who is already struggling.
Just keep going. Push through. Be stronger. You'll be right.
Sometimes people need more than encouragement to keep going.
They need an opportunity to recognise what's happening before everything becomes overwhelming.
That's the thinking behind my Capacity Before Crisis work.
What if we helped boys and men understand their capacity before they reached breaking point?
What if we taught them to recognise the pressures building in their lives?
To understand the difference between what they can control and what they cannot?
To communicate what they're experiencing?
To develop relationships where they can be honest?
And to understand that asking for help doesn't diminish their independence or masculinity?
We can teach men to be responsible and dependable while also teaching them to recognise their limits.
We can value independence while acknowledging that everyone needs support at different times.
We can encourage ambition without making achievement the measure of a man's worth.
And we can celebrate strength without demanding silence.
We need more than different online influencers
I don't think the answer is simply telling boys to stop watching certain people online.
We need to understand why those voices appeal to them in the first place.
If a young man is looking for purpose, guidance, confidence or belonging, where else can he find it?
Who is listening to his questions?
Who is helping him make sense of rejection, uncertainty, relationships and the pressure to succeed?
And who is showing him that masculinity can include kindness, accountability, courage, compassion and emotional honesty?
I think about the role of fathers, grandfathers, uncles, teachers, coaches, employers and community leaders.
We have opportunities every day to demonstrate a healthier understanding of masculinity.
Not by lecturing boys about everything that's wrong with being a man, but by showing them that being a good man can take many different forms.
That being respectful of women doesn't diminish their own worth.
That being vulnerable doesn't mean abandoning responsibility.
That listening can be as powerful as speaking.
And that admitting you need help can be one of the most important decisions you ever make.
This International Men's Day, what are we really celebrating?
I want us to celebrate men.
The fathers, partners, sons, brothers, mates, volunteers and community members who contribute so much to the lives of others.
But I also want us to acknowledge the men who are struggling to find their place, questioning their worth or carrying things nobody else knows about.
Men who feel they have failed.
Men who are lonely.
Men whose lives haven't turned out the way they expected.
Men who have lost the roles or relationships that once defined them.
I want them to know they still have value.
That their worth isn't determined by their bank balance, job title, appearance or ability to hide their emotions.
And I want young men to grow up understanding that masculinity doesn't have to be a performance.
We don't need to replace one rigid definition of manhood with another.
We need to give boys and men the freedom to develop their own identity, build healthy relationships, contribute to their communities and seek support when life becomes difficult.
The measure of a man's strength shouldn't be how much he can carry without anyone noticing.
Maybe it's also his capacity to recognise when the load is becoming too much, to let others in and to be there when someone else needs him.
Because masculinity should strengthen our ability to live, love, connect and contribute.
It shouldn't come at the expense of our mental health.
And as we approach International Men's Day, I think we all have a responsibility to ask:
Are we raising boys who feel secure in who they are, or boys who will spend their lives trying to prove they're man enough?
That's a conversation worth having.
If this conversation brings up something difficult, support is available. Lifeline: 13 11 14. MensLine Australia: 1300 78 99 78. If someone's life is in immediate danger, call 000.
Research and further reading
Australian Bureau of Statistics — Intentional self-harm (suicide) deaths, 2025.
Movember Institute — Young Men's Health in a Digital World.
Australia's eSafety Commissioner — The manosphere: What it is and what parents and carers need to know.
Ford & Keane (2024) — Australian men's help-seeking intentions for anxiety symptoms: The impact of masculine norm conformity and gender role conflict.